|
The Jewish Community of the South Manchester
Suburb
of Didsbury
1891-1914:
a socio-economic comparison with the Northern sector of the city's
Jewry
Introduction
This paper stems from a local history paper I wrote
in 1996 for a degree module on the formation of the Didsbury Jewry
between 1891 and 1914. Situated
five miles south of Manchester, Didsbury has long been known for its
thriving Jewish community, colloquially called "Yidsbury" and "Palestine
Road" in reference to Palatine Road.
The project arose not from personal faith – I am not
Jewish – but from a long-standing interest in Didsbury’s local history,
where I have lived for much of my adult life. I was struck by the lack
of published research on Didsbury’s Jewish community, despite its
significant presence and cultural contribution. An appreciation of
Didsbury’s period architecture, many examples of which once housed
prominent Jewish families, also drew me to the subject, alongside a
broader interest in genealogy and social history.
|
Palatine Road / Lapwing Lane Junction
Tram / Bus Terminus - West Didsbury
|
|
 |
 |
|
Tram terminus 1912
Courtesy
Manchester Library &
Information Service |
Bus terminus 2005
Author's collection |
For the purpose of this
research, I have included the neighbouring suburb of Withington, as many
members of its Jewish community resided along major thoroughfares like
Palatine Road and Wilmslow Road, which traverse both areas. Determining
precise boundary lines on these roads proved challenging, and excluding
certain historically significant individuals simply because they lived
just beyond the Didsbury border would have resulted in the omission of
people whose lives and activities were closely connected to the Didsbury
Jewish community.
1. Aims and Strategy
Following
a primarily hypothesis-testing strategy,
the aim of this study is to identify socio-economic divisions
between the Manchester Jewish communities. By focusing on the Didsbury
Jewish community
during 1891-1914, divisions
were expected to emerge between this group and the northern sector
of the city’s Jewry, which was the focus of Williams (1976).
The hypotheses tested are
drawn
from Englander (1994, p.184), that ‘separation of classes affected the
Manchester Jewish minority as much as the general population’ in that:
a) affluent Jews moved
southward away from the city’s Jewish enclave, towards and into the
middle-class suburb of Didsbury.
b) further social divisions
within the Didsbury Jewish community existed between the Sephardi and
Ashkenazi Jews.
c) assimilation into mainstream middle-class society was
prevalent amongst the more affluent Didsbury Jewish figures, which created further
social divisions between the community.
Due to time factors and word
limitations for this study, no attempt was made to distinguish between
orthodox and non-orthodox Jews.
2. Relation to the
work of other researchers
Class divisions amongst Jewish communities are documented by
Williams (1976), Englander (1994), Waterman (Pryce, 1994) and Price (1984).
Although the time scale of the work of some of these researchers is
different, they have nevertheless, conducted critical research in areas
which is relevant to my work.
Williams, in
The Making of Manchester Jewry: 1740-1875 (1976)
provides valuable statistical data for making quantitative socio-economic
comparison and important contextual information on the origins of
Manchester Jewry. He demonstrates that the principal suburban movement
from around 1815 was northwards towards Broughton, with a smaller
southward movement into areas such as Chorlton-on-Medlock and Rusholme.
This is significant to the present research, as trade directory and
census data show that many Didsbury Jewish residents followed a similar
southward migration route through these areas. Gustav Behrens (a wealthy Jewish merchant), for
example, lived on Plymouth Grove, Chorlton-on-Medlock in 1881-86 before
moving to Didsbury. Novelist Elizabeth Gaskell also lived
on Plymouth
Grove until her death in 1865 and assimilation into mainstream
middle-class society is evident amongst her Jewish neighbours who
socialised at her house - it was a ‘social centre’ for ‘Jewish as well as
non-Jewish’ (Williams, 1976, p 169).
Waterman and Englander identify similar patterns of
Jewish suburbanisation in other cities. Waterman’s study of Jewish
settlement in Dublin shows a progression from clustered segregation to
suburban dispersal, as prosperous families moved outward, with suburbs
subsequently attracting further migration and institutional development
(Pryce, 1994, p.166).
Englander’s study of East London demonstrates
comparable class-based spatial divisions, identified through synagogue
distribution. He notes the establishment of new synagogues in the West
End as a result of ‘the westward march of the wealthy’ (Englander, 1994,
p.184). Similarly, new synagogues were founded in South Manchester from
1872 to serve the expanding middle-class suburban Jewish population.
By way of illustration, Mrs Brewer’s
article (1892), Englander also highlights the predominance of
working-class immigrant trades such as tailoring and cap making within
the East End Jewry. These patterns also appear in Manchester Jewry, in
contrast to the Didsbury Jewish population, which was dominated by
wealthier shipping and commercial occupations.
A major question raised in my research was what brought Jews to Didsbury.
Although several factors were influential, including cleaner air and
improved transport, educational opportunities were particularly
significant given the area’s academic character. Williams’ research
shows that the Jewish community placed emphasis on education as ‘an
instrument of social change’ (1976, p.89), particularly as a route into
the professions. ‘The movement of Jews into the professions had begun
when Jacob Nathan sent his son, Lewis Henry, to Manchester Grammar
School ... and on to London to train as a surgeon’ (Williams, 1976,
p.123). This study reveals similar aspirations among numerous Didsbury
Jewish parents.
Elias Canetti,
Jewish author of
The Tongue Set Free
(1988), for instance, lived in Didsbury as a child and recalls his father’s
response to his wish to become a doctor, ‘You don’t have to become a
businessman like me and the uncles. You will go to the university and you
will be what you want most’ (Canetti, 1988, p.42).
A less explicit factor that may have drawn Jews to
Didsbury relates to Anglo-Jewish leadership, who perceived the
conditions and lifestyles of poorer Jewish communities as obstacles to
integration into British society (Englander, 1994, p.185). Williams
similarly suggests that early Jewish settlers in South Manchester moved
southwards to distance themselves from their social inferiors (Williams,
1976, p.313).
Evidence relating to socio-economic divisions within
the Didsbury Jewish community itself supports Price (1984), who argues
that such divisions were evident between Sephardi and Ashkenazi Jews,
with Sephardim clustering in the prestigious Palatine Road area (Price,
1984, p.44).
To compare the socio-economic divisions between the North and South
Manchester Jewish communities, Armstrong (Drake and Finnegan, 1994) and
Rau’s (1984) class indicators have been used which will be discussed under
Section 3.
3. Sources and Methods
The main primary sources used were the Manchester
Trade Directories.
Working back from 1891 to 1869 at five yearly intervals, I extracted
names, addresses (including business address) and occupations of Jewish
residents. The objective was to analyse migratory patterns and classify
Didsbury residents’ socio-economic status by occupation and type of
residence.
The number of Jewish residents living in Didsbury at
each interval indicated that the community began to become established
during the late 1880s. Local amenities such as schools, transport and
recreational facilities were also recorded. However, evidence of
specifically Jewish institutions was limited. Apart from a kosher
butcher that opened in 1914, no synagogues or registered Jewish
institutions appear to have been established in the area during this
period.
A major limitation of the directories was that many of the residents
were listed under the private resident section, in which occupations were
not recorded. Many occupations therefore remain unidentified. Another limitation was my lack of familiarity with untypical
Jewish surnames, which presented challenges in identifying individuals.
I therefore supplemented my data with the trade directory compilation by
Price (1984), which also identified additional Jewish names and
distinguished between Ashkenazi and Sephardi origins.
Several methods were adopted to test the middle-class credentials of the
Didsbury Jewish community. By comparing them with the northern sector of
the city’s Jewry, I consulted the statistical data from
Williams
(1976). From the Manchester and Salford censuses, he extracted individuals
who belonged to the Jewish community between 1841 and 1871. I focused on
his data for 1871 since it was the closest year to my study period. A
particularly useful set of data he provides from them is the occupations
of 1,170 Jewish workers (1976, pp.358-360). I then used Armstrong’s
classification (Drake and
Finnegan, 1994, pp.48-49) to compare
all known occupations of both communities.
As the occupations of numerous Didsbury Jewish residents remained elusive
to me, and Armstrong’s classification often failed to align with
available data, I consulted the 1891 census. This allowed me to uncover
additional class indicators, such as whether the householders were
categorized as ‘employed’ or ‘employers’, which helped to address gaps
left by missing occupational data. The keeping of servants was one
middle-class indicator which Rau discusses in her article ‘Who Chose Chalcots?’ (Offprints
1, Article 2) and this is significant since the
census
showed
that Jewish householders kept an average of three servants. Another
middle-class indicator identified by Rau was out-migration from the
central areas of the city. The children’s place and date of birth were
therefore recorded as indicators of the length of time the family had
lived in the area, their previous area of residence and whether their move
involved step migration to more desirable areas. The householders’
birthplace indicated whether they had migrated directly from another
country or town. The names of male children were also cross-checked
against the Manchester Grammar School (1965) register of old Mancunians
(see below for objective).
Had the
censuses been accessible up to 1914, as were the
directories, they would have been the most fruitful source because of
their standardisation into categories which enable comparisons of
statistical data to be made. Their limitations, however, are that the
handwriting is not always legible and some occupants may not have been home
on census night. The possibility of illiteracy or untruthfulness was also
taken into consideration.
To delve into the social dynamics within the community and explore
potential assimilation into mainstream society, I examined various
primary literary sources in search of familiar names. Obituaries,
extracted from newspaper clippings, shed light on the remarkable
accomplishments and active contributions of prominent Didsbury Jewish
figures to the broader community. Elias Canetti's autobiography
The Tongue Set Free
(1988) offered a vivid portrayal of his childhood within the Didsbury
Jewish community, intertwining narratives of notable Jewish figures
associated with his family. Additionally, I consulted A
Biographical Register of Old Mancunians 1888-1951 (1965) to
glean insights into former pupils of Manchester Grammar School, renowned
for its history of attracting Jewish students. The identification of
registered Didsbury Jewish pupils within this register provided
corroborative evidence of their integration into mainstream society.
To develop a more nuanced understanding of the community, I conducted an
interview with a Jewish couple, referred to as Mr. and Mrs. 'A', whose
parents resided in Didsbury in 1914-15. Given the necessity to probe
specific hypotheses and address gaps in knowledge within a constrained
timeframe, I opted for a structured interview format with predetermined,
open-ended questions. Throughout the process, I maintained the anonymity
of the interviewees by employing pseudonyms. All other individuals are
identified by their real names only where those names appear in publicly
available published materials.
Numerous field studies of the area were also
undertaken, with the aid of ordinance survey maps and lists of relevant
addresses taken from
censuses. These included
examination of surviving houses for class identification, and examination
of the local Jewish burial ground (situated in Southern Cemetery) for any
relevant evidence.
Because of the volume of data involved, this was entered into a database
(see Table 1 sample), which proved a valuable aid in analysing the
community’s southward suburban movement. It also enabled identification
of Ashkenazi and Sephardi Jews and residents of individual suburbs and
streets at various time intervals.
Table 1
–
Sample database of
Didsbury Jewish residents in 1905
|
Name |
Tradition |
Address |
Area |
Occupation |
|
Abdela, Suvi |
S |
17
Clyde Rd |
AP |
Cotton manufacturing agent |
|
Arditti, Joseph |
S |
55
Clyde Rd |
AP |
Shipping merchant, exporter of cotton goods
|
|
Arditti, Samuel |
S |
144 Barlow Moor Rd |
WD |
Shipping merchant S. Arditti Bros. |
|
Aronsberg, Aaron |
A |
3
Rathen Rd |
W |
Optician |
|
Ascoli,
Ephraim |
S |
26
Wilmslow Rd |
W |
Shipping merchant |
|
Baerlein, Max |
A |
131
Wilmslow Rd |
W |
Merchant & engineer |
|
Behrens, Guustav |
A |
30
Palatine Rd |
W |
Shipping
merchant Sir Jacob & Son |
|
Behrens, Henry |
A |
Darley Ave |
WD |
Merchant Beatty, Altgelt & Co. |
|
Bezazienne, David |
S |
19
Cresswell Gr |
AP |
Agent for grey cloth merchant |
|
Cobe,
Myer |
A |
195
Burton Rd |
WD |
Manufacturer |
|
Cohen, Barnet |
A |
28
Palatine Rd |
W |
India rubber goods manufacturer |
|
Cohen, Max |
A |
7
Amhurst St |
W |
Shipping merchant |
|
Cohen,
Samuel J. |
A |
2
Mauldeth Rd |
W |
Export Of Cotton Goods |
|
Goldschmidt,
Herman J. |
A |
200
Wilmslow Rd |
W |
Contractor & merchant / Alderman |
|
Hesse,
Frank R. |
A |
135 Barlow Moor Rd |
W |
Don Jewish board of guardians |
|
Isaacs,
Isaac Judah |
S |
75
Palatine Rd |
W |
Shipper of grey cloths calico prints |
|
Israels, Herman |
A |
29
Goulden Rd |
W |
Manager India warehouse |
|
Karnofski, Joseph |
A |
11
Pattern St |
W |
Householder |
|
Klein, Joseph |
S |
33
Clyde Rd |
AP |
Manager |
|
Lazarus, Julius |
A |
1
Wilmslow Rd |
AP |
Merchant & manufacturing agent |
|
Levy,
Henry |
A |
84
Wilmslow Rd |
AP |
Clerk |
|
Menasee,
Nessim A. |
S |
154
Clyde Rd |
WD |
Shipping merchant cotton goods |
|
Meyer, Adolph |
A |
60
Egerton Rd |
W |
Buyer (Manchester export trade) |
|
Morreau, Marcus |
A |
139
Lapwing Ln |
D |
Shipping merchant |
|
Oppenheim,
Frederick |
A |
11
Elm Rd |
D |
Solicitor |
|
Rapaport, Isidor |
A |
7
Atwood Rd |
D |
Export Merchant |
|
Rofe,
David |
S |
20
Palatine Rd |
W |
General shipping merchant |
|
Rothkof, Jacob |
A |
63
Clyde Rd |
AP |
Manufactures agent and merchant in drapery goods |
|
Saul,Barnett |
A |
42
Wilmslow Rd |
W |
Physician BA LSA |
|
Saul,
Helen (Mrs) |
A |
42
Wilmslow Rd |
W |
Physician LSA |
|
Schloss, Elkin |
A |
7
Stanton Av |
WD |
Merchant |
|
Simmons, Samuel |
A |
14
Cooper St |
W |
Coachman |
|
Simonsen, Lionel |
A |
15
Circular Rd |
W |
Velveteen merchant |
|
Somech, David |
S |
43
Parsonage Rd |
W |
Occupation not recorded |
|
Steinthal, Arthur |
A |
38
Landsdown Rd |
AP |
Merchant/employer |
|
Steinthal,Edgar Fredrick |
A |
17
Didsbury Pk |
D |
Shipping merchant |
|
Susmann Mrs, JUlie |
A |
9
Wilmslow Rd |
D |
Occupation not recorded |
|
Weingold,
Samuel H. |
A |
11
Egerton Rd |
W |
Wholesale jeweller |
Area key: AP - Albert Park; WD - West Didsbury; W - Withington; D -
Didsbury
Sources:
Manchester Trade Directories
4. Findings
The pattern of out-migration from the central areas of the city towards
the south is significant in these findings, as in the study by Rau
(1984) and Waterman (Pryce, 1994), in that this movement was undertaken predominantly by middle-class Jews.
Migration moved southwards through Chorlton-on-Medlock, Rusholme and
Fallowfield towards and into the suburb of Didsbury.
Seigmund
Oppenheim, one of the first Ashkenazi Jews to settle in South
Manchester around 1873 also followed this southward pattern of
out-migration. Arriving from Hamburg he resided in Lytham, as well as his
town house in Oxford Street, Rusholme, before moving by 1911 to the 'Parkfield'
residence on Parkfield Road in Didsbury. As Table 2 shows there were only
four Jewish households in the Didsbury area in 1871, which, by 1914, had
increased to 103.
Table 2 –
Number of Jewish households
identified in the Didsbury area
|
|
1871 |
1891 |
1900 |
1905 |
1910 |
1914 |
|
Ashkenazi |
2 |
11 |
33 |
29 |
31 |
38 |
|
Sephardi |
? |
4 |
6 |
10 |
40 |
65 |
|
Total |
3 |
15 |
39 |
39 |
71 |
103 |
Sources:
Census Enumerators' Books
for 1891 and Manchester
Trade Directories
1869-1914
Observation of Jewish
family residences reveals a stark contrast between those in the northern
sector of the city's Jewry and those in Didsbury, where many Jews had
relocated. The 1891 census reveals that most Didsbury Jewish residents
lived in large villas or palatial mansions set in their own grounds,
typically employing an average of three servants. In sharp contrast, the
northern sector of the city's Jewry was dominated by rows of terraced
houses in densely populated areas. In 1871, over one-third of its
inhabitants lived in the notorious Red Bank district of Cheetham Hill.
|
Red Bank from
Foundry Street 1904 |
|
 |
|
Courtesy
Manchester Library &
Information Service |
The directories show a marked
improvement in transport facilities in Didsbury with the opening in the
early 1880s of railway lines and horse-bus services (followed by electric trams
from 1902) running from Didsbury to the city centre. This was likely to
have influenced Jewish settlement in the area, as most Jewish residents
worked in or near the city centre. As the map in Appendix 4 shows, a
large proportion of Jewish settlement
was concentrated in the
Albert Park area, which
lay within a short walking distance to the Withington & Albert Park
Railway Station on Lapwing
Lane and the horse-bus terminus on Palatine Road, West Didsbury.
|
Tram Terminus
Palatine Road 1908 |
|
Withington/Albert
Park Train Station 1912
|
 |
|
 |
|
Courtesy
Manchester Library &
Information Service |
Educational opportunities, in
particular, appear to have drawn Jewish families to Didsbury. The
directories list a wealth of educational establishments in the area and
surrounding districts, and
Mr and Mrs 'A' stated (1996) that many
local Jewish
children attended preparatory schools before progressing to the local
grammar schools. Mr 'A' himself attended the highly academic and
prestigious Manchester Grammar School
while his wife attended the
equivalent Withington Girls’ School.
A Biographical Register of Old Mancunians 1888-1951 confirms that numerous Jewish boys from Didsbury
gained entry into the
Manchester Grammar
School. Ephraim Ascoli, a Sephardi shipping merchant of
Wilmslow Road, for example, sent his
four sons to the
school between 1894 and 1906.
His second eldest
son, Francis, became Managing Director of Dunlop Plantations Ltd. (MGS,
1965). Some Manchester Grammar School pupils, such as Leonard Behrens (son of Gustav
Behrens)
and Louis Rosenberg, moved on to Manchester University (Owens College
until1903) which was a short tram-ride from Didsbury.
|
Manchester
University Owens College 1910 |
|
 |
|
Courtesy
Manchester Library &
Information Service |
This class indicator contrasts
sharply with the
educational profile of the northern sector of the city. By the turn
of the century,
The Jews School
on
Derby Street had a child population of 2,000 (Williams, 1988, p.63).
Unlike the non-Jewish preparatory schools in Didsbury, which
emphasised academic attainment, The Jews School ‘reflected working-class
needs’ (Williams,
1976, p. 330). Girls were encouraged to develop domestic skills, while boys were prepared for apprenticeship schemes.
In contrast to the
occupations identified in Williams’ research, in which 75% were
working-class (Class III or IV) ‘immigrant’ trades (33% being tailors),
the occupations and lifestyles of the Didsbury Jews indicate that 36%
belonged to Class I, 56% to Class II, and only 8% to Class III of
Armstrong’s classification. Only 5% of the Jews in Williams’ study
belonged to Class I and 8% to Class II; as little as 4% kept servants
and 33% lived in the Cheetham Hill ghetto area.
Table 3 –
Occupations of the Didsbury Jewish Community, 1891–1914
|
Occupation |
Ashkenazi |
Sephardi |
|
Barrister |
1 |
|
|
Butcher (kosher) |
1 |
|
|
Clerk |
1 |
|
|
Commission agent |
|
1 |
|
Contractor |
2 |
|
|
Engineer |
2 |
|
|
Furrier |
1 |
|
|
Householder |
5 |
7 |
|
Jeweller (wholesale) |
1 |
|
|
Manufacturer |
2 |
1 |
|
Manager |
1 |
|
|
Merchant |
15 |
25 |
|
Physician |
2 |
|
|
Picture dealer |
1 |
|
|
Retailing chain |
1 |
|
|
Solicitor |
1 |
|
|
Surgeon |
1 |
|
|
Tailor |
1 |
|
|
Tobacconist |
1 |
|
|
Traveller |
1 |
|
|
Unknown |
51 |
54 |
Sources:
1891 census
and
Manchester Trade Directories 1891-1914
There is also a marked difference between the occupations of the Didsbury
Jewish groups. The vast
majority of Sephardim were cotton shipping merchants, whereas a diversity
of occupations, including professions, is evident amongst the Ashkenazim
(see Table 3). Although I found no
professional status amongst the Didsbury Jews in the directory and census data
for 1891, by 1914 there
were two physicians, one surgeon, one solicitor, one barrister, and two
engineers, all of whom were
Ashkenazi Jews.
Kirsten
Beach has confirmed that the
one solicitor
cited,
Frederick
Oppenheim, practised at the law firm Vaudrey,
Oppenheim and Mellor on Oxford Street (Slater’s Directories 1903 and 1911)
and it seems that his father, Siegmund, was also connected to the firm
through his role as
a Justice of the
Peace. For many Ashkenazim in Didsbury, professional status appears to
have been valued as a form of long-term security - something that could
not be easily taken away through antisemitic policies or upheaval,
unlike a business. While Sephardim also faced persecution in various
parts of the world, the Ashkenazi experience in Eastern Europe may have
made this emphasis on secure professions especially meaningful.
For those unable to afford
the educational qualifications leading to a professional career, various
businesses were established
alongside merchant activities. Mr
'A'’s
father, for instance,
built a successful retailing chain of menswear retailers from 1905, which grew to
nearly thirty
branches nationwide.
Divisions between the
Didsbury Sephardi and Ashkenazi Jews are most evident in the separate
synagogal provisions in South Manchester. The Withington Congregation of
Spanish and Portuguese Jews (est. 1904) on Mauldeth Road catered to the
Sephardi community, while the South Manchester Synagogue (est. 1872),
which moved from All Saints to Wilbraham Road in 1913, served the
Ashkenazim. This segregation extends to the Jewish cemetery, where each
congregation has its own plots. The Manchester Reform congregation plots
are located closest to the entrance gates and the prayer chapel,
followed by the South Manchester (Ashkenazi) section, with the Maurice
Mesrie (Sephardic) graves situated at the back.
Data on residential patterns
support Price’s finding (1984) that the Sephardim
clustered along the prestigious Palatine Road. This was particularly evident
during 1910-14, when an influx of Sephardim settled there.
Solomon Arditti, a maternal uncle of Elias Canetti,
for instance, moved from Cairnfieild, 124 Barlow Moor Road, in 1913 to 'The Rossett', 123 Palatine Road. House sale
transactions were also frequently made between the same group of Jews.
Directory data show that Solomon Arditti sold 'Cairnfieild' on
Barlow Moor Road
to David Menashe
and bought ‘The Rossett’ on Palatine Road from Joseph Smouha - all three being Sephardi Jews.
Likewise, Ernest Horkheimer sold his ‘Holly Royde’ mansion
at 30 Palatine Road between 1891 and 1895 to Gustav Behrens - both
men being
Ashkenazi
Jews.
Mr. and Mrs. 'A' emphasised that although they were in a ‘mixed marriage’
- Mr. 'A' being Ashkenazi and Mrs. 'A' Sephardi - such unions were
uncommon in their parents' generation. During that time, social
divisions between the two groups were pronounced.
|
Holly Royde - 30 Palatine Road |
|

Author's collection |
|
|
|
Author's collection
The home of
Gustav Behrens from 1894 -1944, one of the community's wealthiest
Ashkenazi
shipping merchants. Now
(1996) owned by Manchester University, functioning as a conference
centre, and donated to the university in memory of Gustav and his
wife, Fanny.
|
|
234 Burton Road, West Didsbury |
 |
|
Author's collection, 2011
Once the childhood home of Elias Canetti,
winner of the 1981
Nobel Prize in Literature. Canetti vividly describes his
time here until his father's death in 1912 in
his memoir The Tongue Set Free (1988). The house has since
been re-numbered 292.
|
Assimilation into mainstream
middle-class society has been shown to be most prominent amongst the affluent
Ashkenazi
members of the community.
Cretien Gradisky, for instance,
represented Didsbury Ward on the City Council (Obituary), Israel Sieff,
co-founder
of Marks and Spencer, donated £5,000 to the
Manchester Grammar
School (Graham and Phythian, 1965, p.86) and Gustav Behrens was chairman
of the Hallé
Concert’s
Society and a director of the Chamber of Commerce (Obituary).
Siegmund
Oppenheim also participated at a high level in the local community
as Vice-Consul, and Justice of the Peace, and Magistrate.
The evidence suggests that the community’s children attending
non-Jewish
schools is likely to have promoted their assimilation into mainstream
society, as would their upward mobility into the professions.
Mr and Mrs 'A', however, recall that
despite their mainstream education and friendships with non-Jewish
school peers, their parents rarely socialised outside the Jewish circle.
Most of their recreational time was spent engaged in charity work,
literary and dramatic societies, and concerts, particularly
in support of the Jewish community’s younger members.
5.
Conclusions
This study has found, through
analysis of various class indicators (such as occupations, education and
servant-keeping), significant socio-economic divisions between the
Manchester Jewish communities of Didsbury and the northern sector of the
city’s Jewry. Divisions were also found between the Didsbury Sephardi and
Ashkenazi
Jews. Although there were many wealthy Ashkenazim, it was the
Sephardim who held the reputation associated with wealth and elitism.
Yet, unlike some prominent Ashkenazim who assimilated into mainstream
middle-class society, the Sephardim were more inclined to ‘keep themselves
to themselves’, as evidenced by their residential clustering patterns and
shared occupations as shipping merchants. This study, then, bears out the
wider comparative findings of other researchers in confirming the
hypotheses that ‘separation of classes affected the Manchester Jewish
minority as much as the general population’.
To close on a personal
note, a particularly rewarding aspect of this project has been the hands-on experience of using primary sources such as
census records
and interviewing surviving relatives. The excitement of tracing missing links
through such sources has made this study a most enjoyable pursuit.
6.
Bibliography
Brewer, Mrs 1892 'The Jewish
Colony in London - First Paper' in DA301.
Canetti, E. 1988
The
Tongue Set Free, London, Pan Books Ltd.
Collins, Lydia 2006
The Sephardim of
Manchester : Pedigrees and Pioneers,
Manchester, Shaare Hayim
Drake, M. and
Finnegan, R.
(eds.) 1994
Sources and Methods for Family and Community Historians:
A Handbook, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press in association with
The Open University.
Englander, D. 1994 `Jewish
East London, 1850-1950', in Pryce, W.T.R. (ed.) From family history to
community history, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press in
association with The Open University.
Graham, J.A. and Phythian,
B.A. 1965
The Manchester Grammar School -1515-1965, Manchester
University Press.
Price, S.L. 1984 Unpublished
dissertation for Honours degree of BA - The Rise of the Manchester
Jewish Suburbia: a study of intra-urban migration, Department of
Geography University of Nottingham.
Pryce, W.T.R. (ed.) 1994
Volume 2,
From Family History to Community History, Cambridge,
Cambridge University Press in association with The Open University.
Rau, D. 1984 `Who chose Chalcots? Aspects of family and social structure in 1851', in DA301
Offprints Booklet 1, The Open University.
Williams, B. 1976
The making of Manchester Jewry 1740-1875,
Manchester, Manchester University Press.
Williams, B. 1988 Manchester Jewry - A Pictorial History 1788-1988,
Manchester, Archive Publications.
7. Primary
Source References
Census Enumerators' Books,
1891, for Didsbury and
Withington, Manchester Central Library (Local Studies Unit).
Manchester Trade Directories,
1869-1914, of Fallowfield, Withington and Didsbury, Manchester Central
Library (Local Studies Unit).
Manchester Grammar School,
(1965) A Biographical register of Old Mancunians 1888-1951,
Manchester, H. Rawson & Co. Ltd.
Manchester Local Image
Collection, Manchester Library & Information Service, Manchester
Central Library.
Obituaries, Manchester
Newspaper Cuttings, Manchester Central Library (Local Studies Unit).
Oral
Sources
Mr and Mrs 'A' (second
generation Jewish immigrants, Director of men’s retail outfitters).
Interview not recorded. Interviewed in Manchester by Julia Maine (1996).
Website
Visitors Sources
Beach,
Kirsten Heemskerk, Netherlands (for the
Oppenheim/Cassell/Thompson
family). All correspondence via email (2005).
|